Companies

Default Netdania Symbol2-01

NetDania

The best alternative to expensive legacy systems for trading, news and analysis

ttm-UNDERLINED-dark gradient-01

TTMzero

Fully digitized RegTech and capital markets software solutions

FairX symbol-blue gradient-upwards-01

FairXchange

State-of-the-art analytical tools for trading firms

ATHENA Symbol-Dark blue gradient-01

Athena

Workflow automations for buy-side participants

Symbol of CobaltFX logo

CobaltFX

Leading provider of credit & post-trade FX infrastructure

Products

trade icon SVG format

Market Data Solutions

Cutting Edge Technology and Market Data.

brokers SVG icon

Data Visualisation

Advanced Real-Time Data Visualisation

candle sticks SVG icon

Trading Technology

Unleash the power of trading platforms.

valuations-01

Fair Value Pricing

Independent fair value pricing for added transparency where current prices are not readily available

evaluated real time data-01

Evaluated Real-Time Market Data

Independent real-time market data feeds at a fraction of the cost

figures-01

Key Figures and Risk Indicators

Precise indications of the risk and return probabilities for financial products

structured products-01

Financial Instruments Automation Platform

Reliable and cost-effective digitization process for securities and OTC trades

banks SVG icon

Liquidity Management

Unparalleled insight into your trading with data visualization

thumbnailG

Order and Portfolio Management System

Highly flexible Investment Management System

dynamic credit logo

Dynamic Credit

One credit limit - multiple market access points

workflow SVG icon

Post-trade Automation

Eliminate systemic risk, manual processes and reconciliation

TNN-01

Trade Notification Network

Enhances your business’ operational robustness and resilience

Athena, your OMS/PMS platform

  • Dynamic as your business
  • Manage your entire investment process
  • Instantly assess risks & monitor performance
  • Record financial transactions real-time
cover

May 6th 2022

5 min read

The new age of fintech banks: how they evolved from disruption to replacement

As more fintechs acquire full banking licenses, we look at how an industry of challengers has become an industry of imitators.
United Fintech

As more fintechs acquire full banking licenses, we look at how an industry of challengers has become an industry of imitators.

This is part four of our series on the History of Fintech. Read part one, part two, and part three.

 

It’s clear that in the fight between fintechs and banks (if such a fight truly exists), banks have the upper hand.

While the dominant narrative has long been that banks were too big, too burdened, too static to keep up with fast-paced, agile, innovative startups, the truth is that these very qualities were their core advantage. Compared to fintechs, banks still enjoy huge market power, high consumer trust, and access to cheap capital.

To keep the fight alive, some fintechs are leaning into the power imbalance, and seeking banking licenses of their own, while banks have taken different approaches to self-preservation. But while some approaches may yield short-term success, banks (and fintechs) need to have the long game in mind.

 

How banks are fighting back

In the last ten years or so, banks have responded to the rising perceived threat of fintech challengers in a few strategic ways. In this game, the choice of building, buying or partnering is slightly more complex — but not by much.

Acquisition

Old-fashioned M&As are certainly a well-defined concept in the financial industry. Banks may choose to acquire a fintech for its technology, its talent, or its customer base, but this strategy begs the question: is incorporating one’s rival enough to stay competitive? Perhaps this is why flat-out acquisition is one of the less popular options. Still, in the last couple of years, institutions like Fifth Third Bank, Bank of America, and PNC have all acquired a fintech (or two).

Partnership

A bank-fintech partnership can be mutually beneficial, and it allows banks to move more quickly and cost-effectively. For many fintechs, having a banking partner is not only an advantage, it’s a necessity. Banks provide access to valuable APIs and can help fintechs navigate the complex regulatory environment. Fintechs in turn offer access to their technology, often white-labeled for their banking partner.

Find fintech partners without the long wait times or technical risks. Speak with a United Fintech consultant and we’ll help match your requirements with ready-to-go solutions. Book a free demo.

Investment

Investing in fintechs is a way for banks to hedge their risks by betting across the board. It’s a good way to gain an inside look at an evolving space, without investing too many internal resources. Banks may also choose to invest in fintechs with whom they already partner or otherwise utilize.

Digital transformation

If one of the key advantages of being a fintech is agility and flexibility, then perhaps that is what needs to be imported into banking. Certainly many banks have tried to keep pace with tech rivals through digital transformation, reinventing their IT infrastructure and core systems to try and keep pace with the rapid development of fintechs. In other words: if you can’t copy their results, copy their methods.

Internal development

The most ambitious banks have tried to outpace fintechs by developing their own sub-brands, either through internal labs or independent offshoots, “combining the strengths of an incumbent with the agility of a start-up,” as McKinsey puts it. Still, only 7% of banks have created truly independent subsidiaries, mostly preferring to run internal incubator programs.

 

Exposing the underlying conflict of interest

Ultimately, fintechs — or at the very least the market forces that have led to fintech growth — are going to change the way banks do business. As in any tech-dominated industry, ongoing complacency will ultimately lead to obsolescence.

Still, the choice between cooperation (acquisition, partnership, or investment) and competition (transformation, internal development) isn’t so binary. After all, when it comes to cooperation, the ultimate goals can get a bit muddy.

Want access to the best fintech products on a central platform? Our platform reduces costs, drives automation, and delivers efficiency within Capital Markets. Learn more

If a bank’s investment in a fintech goes well, it means the fintech has succeeded where the bank has failed — in essence widening the gap between the bank and its target market. There may be a financial benefit for the bank, but the long-term strategy has not effectively been addressed.

So while cooperation is appealing — and an effective short-term strategy — banks will need to find a way to compete directly by either embracing new tech and rethinking their internal processes and strategies or by relinquishing add-on services to fintechs and focusing on core banking activities.

 How banks are currently responding to the fintech movement

If you can’t beat them, become them

Until now, fintechs have eked out a competitive advantage by providing a novel approach to banking services, putting convenience and service first. These innovative, over-the-top solutions were a testing ground for a new era in financial services, providing a solid proof-of-concept for banks to respond in any of the ways listed above.

Of course, there is another way banks can respond: simply stealing fintech ideas.

Sure, “stealing” may be exaggerating, but the truth is that if the idea is good and the resources are available, there isn’t much stopping banks from recreating the best fintech ideas internally. Fintechs may lead in innovation only to have their idea copied and implemented by a banking rival with superior resources and a broader customer base.

Maybe that’s why some fintechs have become that which they set out to replace: banks.

Beyond rebundling there’s rebanking

Some fintechs have taken stock of their situation and decided that their best chance at disrupting banks was to become a bank. Early fintechs (those founded in the 2000s) have played the long game, waiting a decade or more before taking the leap.

Tyro Payments was the first fintech in Australia to receive a banking license in 2015, 12 years after its initial founding. Two years later in Sweden, Klarna also received its banking license after 12 years of operating in the payments space. In 2020, Britain’s P2P lending platform Zopa received its banking license, a full 15 years after its launch. And in 2021, US-based Lending Club acquired the digital bank Radius, officially obtaining a banking charter 15 years after its founding in 2016.

But newer fintechs are moving faster. Revolut, the UK banking services app, launched in 2015 and by 2018 already had a provisional banking charter, which was extended to a full banking license in 2020.

Not only does acquiring a banking license open up new opportunities for financial services, it’s a savvy move for fintechs looking to reduce costs. According to Lending Club CEO Scott Sanborn, their fintech paid an average of $20 million a year to issuing banks.

So what does the future hold for fintechs and banks? Will the distinction between them even exist?

In our next and final installment, we’ll look at what the future holds for banks, fintechs, and whatever hybrid, bundled, decentralized venture may yet arise.

 

About United Fintech

United Fintech offers the best fintech products on one central platform. We enable banks and financial institutions to access innovative digital technologies — including real-time data, trading charts, and financial news — by partnering with engineering-led fintech companies with proven capital markets products.

Learn more at https://unitedfintech.com/

Trends

Myths from the FX industry
Research

MythBusters: Why Addressing the Credit Issue should be a priority for FX trading desks

The Global Forex Exchange Division (GFXD) is galvanising the FX industry to implement dynamic, real-time credit…

3 min read

GFDX encourages dynamic credit
News

GFXD Calls for Greater Use of Dynamic Credit

Explore how the GFXD is leading the charge for dynamic credit solutions in the FX market.…
greater profitability and more control with CobaltFX
Products

Bringing Back Control to FX Credit

Credit is one of the least understood systemic problems facing the FX market, yet it is…

3 min read